Katie Kaufmann is convinced her life is over. Katie's boyfriend, Marcus Spencer, has cruelly kicked her out of the house they share, and leaving Colorado to move back into her family's farmhouse feels like the epitome of failure. However, when she's seated next to Dr. Charlie Warren on the flight home, life back in small-town Texas begins to not look so bad.

As this new relationship blossoms, Katie's heart also turns back to the Lord. Yet even with the many positive changes, she can't understand why she continues to make mistakes. Why is it so hard to live out the Christian faith? And why does it bother everyone that she looks to her best friend, Josh McConnelly, for encouragement? As Katie wrestles with these questions she realizes that she must take an honest look at her life and her choices if she's going to find her way to forever.